Ponus Ridge Woman Files Lawsuit Appealing Neighbor’s Expansion Plans

Saying a neighbor’s plan to expand an antique home—coupled with plans to acquire the adjacent, long-disused Ponus Ridge Chapel and convert it into a private dwelling—would diminish home values in the area, a town woman is appealing a recent decision by the New Canaan Zoning Board of Appeals. Elizabeth Weed in a new lawsuit is seeking to nullify a variance granted Nov. 3 to her next-door neighbors on Ponus Ridge, the Hayeses. The variance would allow them to build an addition to the rear of their home within what technically is the front yard setback—in fact, the entire ca. 1840 house is located within that setback (many 18th and 19th Century homes are situated very close to the road).

Ponus Ridge Homeowners Seek to Build Two-Story Addition on ca. 1840 House

Zoning officials on Monday will hear from a Ponus Ridge homeowner seeking to remodel partly and build a two-story addition to their antique house that would include a new master bedroom. The owners of 394 Ponus Ridge, between Ponus Ridge Chapel and corner of Davenport Ridge Road, are seeking a variance to the required 45-foot front yard setback for reconstruction of an existing screened porch and to build an addition to their ca. 1840 home to accommodate their family’s burgeoning interests and activities while preserving the character of their home and changing minimally its appearance from the street. The current zoning regulations would put the front yard setback more than halfway into the house itself, they say. Reached by NewCanaanite.com, Brendan Hayes said that the family’s goal is to maintain and respect the historic nature of the house and property.

Once a Community Hub, Ponus Ridge Chapel at the Center of Lawsuits

“Do you remember … The New Year’s Eve gathering which consisted of service followed by social and refreshments in the basement? … The mid-week prayer meeting in the first meeting house on Davenport Ridge—a small dog wandered in and up to where Mr. Levi Weed was kneeling in prayer, the dog jumped up on Mr. Weed’s back, sniffed his head and then jumped down and wandered out again … The time Ann Augusta Scofield became hungry during service so left long enough to go to Polly Weed’s kitchen and get something to eat?”

These are some of the warm, neighborly details featured on an early page of the Nov. 4, 1951 pamphlet “The Ponus Ridge Chapel Memorial Program”—a program and event marking the 40th anniversary of a beloved structure that served as both church and community center for scores of New Canaanites. Up to and for more than a decade after that anniversary, the 1,400-square-foot chapel on Ponus Ridge—just a few hundred feet north of Davenport Ridge Road—functioned as gathering place for important community events: church services, Sunday School, group dinners, fairs, christenings, weddings, a funeral, dancing and art classes, holiday parties and meetings of the Ladies’ Aid Society, Farm Bureau and Fish and Game League. Dilapidated now from years of neglectful disuse, its grounds overgrown and verdure encroaching on the fieldstone structure itself, Ponus Ridge Chapel hardly fits the image of a community hub it once held.